as the title says is melee evasion still messed up? just wondering about making a tunic with evasion, but if evasion i smessed up I can wait obviously. thanks for your help.

If your refering to melee evasion the skill
+ 143 melee evasion ( 3.4% vs a lvl50) then no its not working imho.  Its like + 143 melee dmg rating (3.4% vs lvl 50) Sure they both add to evasion/damage but it doesnt directly add that much % wise.  I think at most i had was +300 melee evasion and i say maybe a 2% across the board increase to defense. 

Point for point, i beleive it goes like tihs
parry %(martial swords)> + dodge > +parry skill > +melee evasion

The reasons are pretty simple, the parry % on martial swords directly increases your parry % by the said ammount with relationship to level.  So +20% vs a lvl 53 might add 25% vs a lvl 50.   Dodge (from my personal experiance) adds more avoidance then parry point for point, and melee evasion is an indirect modifier of overal avoidance.

I was under the impression that any bonus to melee evasion was applied prior to other mods (Parry / Dodge). I do remember that I had a level 30 ish tunic of avoidance back in the day and iirc the evasion was modified by the amount in the tool tip. I was obsessed with accurate accounting of those modifiers so I was able to break everything down and it was accurate..... was being the accurate word.

 I will ask around to see if I can get some hard numbers on this.

~QTM

Yes, I would like to know as well if anybody can confirm.  I'm about to purchase a set of T3 flawless with melee evasion all over it.

Thanks for keeping on this one QtM,

I been trying for these answers for a couple months now, so if you get them fill me in to pls.  I believe it's capped and I've heard 35% and I've heard 65%, but my parsing shows a number closer to 50%, so it could go either way. 

My personal testing had numbers pointed roughly to that, as did Sung's,  3 seperate sources are saying roughly the same thing. While not an official notification I think we can make a leap of logic.

~QTM